Christmas Specials | All uncreated men are equal

Should we care about people who need never exist?

How do you value a life not yet lived?

In 1852 the HMS Birkenhead, carrying troops to fight the Xhosa wars, struck a rock near Danger Point in what is now South Africa. The soldiers assembled quietly at the ship’s stern, while the women and children on board clambered to safety on a small boat tethered alongside. Over 440 men lost their lives, drowned, crushed, or eaten by sharks.

This article appeared in the Christmas Specials section of the print edition under the headline “All uncreated men are equal”

From the December 24th 2022 edition

Discover stories from this section and more in the list of contents

Explore the edition

More from Christmas Specials

The year as told through illustrations

Our art department staff looked back to highlight some of their favourites from the past year

A year of our visual journalism

In 2024 we found new ways to cover a range of topics, from war to the future of energy—and, of course, elections.


A network of volunteers is rescuing dogs and cats by bringing them north

Tens of thousands of animals are moved to new states each year, so they can find homes


The beginning of the end for oil in California

What happens to an oil town when the drilling stops?

What a 70-year-old firebreathing lizard reveals about humanity

Each incarnation of Godzilla reflects the fears of its time

What a fourth-century drinking game tells you about contemporary China

China’s obsession with calligraphy colours its view of itself