Business | Bartleby

Why the bullshit-jobs thesis may be, well, bullshit

David Graeber’s theory isn’t borne out by the evidence

MOST PEOPLE feel, from time to time, that their work is meaningless. David Graeber, the late anthropologist, built an elaborate thesis out of this insight. He argued in a book in 2018 that society has been deliberately creating more and more “bullshit jobs” in professions such as financial services to fill the time of educated workers who need the money to pay off student debts but who suffer from depression because of their work. His thesis has been cited more than 800 times by academics, according to Google Scholar, and often repeated in the media.

This article appeared in the Business section of the print edition under the headline “Detecting the real bullshit”

The new geopolitics of big business

From the June 5th 2021 edition

Discover stories from this section and more in the list of contents

Explore the edition

More from Business

A surreal scene with a striped bowl holding the Statue of Liberty's torch, surrounded by floating, distorted faces and small planets.

Donald Trump’s America will not become a tech oligarchy

Reasons not to panic about the tech-industrial complex

A simple robot face with rolls of cash as eyes. The robot has a smiling mouth and a small antenna on top. The design is minimal, with black outlines on a light background.

OpenAI’s latest model will change the economics of software

The more reasoning it does, the more computer power it uses


Protesters in favour of TikTok stand outside the United States Capitol.

TikTok’s time is up. Can Donald Trump save it?

The imperilled app hopes for help from an old foe


The UFC, Dana White and the rise of bloodsport entertainment

There is more to the mixed-martial-arts impresario than his friendship with Donald Trump

Will Elon Musk scrap his plan to invest in a gigafactory in Mexico?

Donald Trump’s return to the White House may have changed Tesla’s plans