United States | The quality of mercy

Two presidents compete over the worst abuse of the pardon power

Donald Trump and Joe Biden have both made indefensible decisions

US President Donald Trump signs executive orders during the inaugural parade inside Capital One Arena, in Washington, DC.
Photograph: Getty Images
|WASHINGTON, DC

American presidents are often disappointed to discover limits to their authority, but the country’s founders intended the nearly absolute pardon power to be an exception. Alexander Hamilton, for example, believed that legislators should not be involved in the pardons process because “one man appears to be a more eligible dispenser of the mercy of government, than a body of men.” Americans might now question the wisdom of bestowing such responsibility on men like Joe Biden and Donald Trump.

Explore more

This article appeared in the United States section of the print edition under the headline “The quality of mercy”

From the January 25th 2025 edition

Discover stories from this section and more in the list of contents

Explore the edition

More from United States

Voters in North Carolina

An unfinished election may shape a swing state’s future

A Supreme Court race ended very close. Then the lawyers arrived.

Migrants from Mexico and Guatemala are apprehended by U.S. Customs and Border Patrol officers after crossing a section of border wall into the U.S.

Donald Trump cries “invasion” to justify an immigration crackdown

His executive orders range from benign to belligerent


A child is silhouetted against a U.S. flag at a rally in support of immigration rights.

To end birthright citizenship, Donald Trump misreads the constitution

A change would also create huge practical problems


Ross Ulbricht, pardoned by Donald Trump, was a pioneer of crypto-crime

His dark website, the Silk Road, was to crime what Napster was to music

Donald Trump has rewritten the history of January 6th

By pardoning violent offenders, he ignored his own team’s advice

Following Trump’s pardons, the Proud Boys are back in the game

Enrique Tarrio tells The Economist he is still figuring out what is next for the group