Leaders | Land reform

Who owns what?

Enforceable property rights are still far too rare in poor countries

TWENTY YEARS ago a Peruvian economist made a startling observation. People in poor countries are not as poor as they seem. They have assets—lots of them. But they cannot prove that they own them, so they cannot use them as collateral. Hernando de Soto estimated that the total value of informally owned land, homes and other fixed assets was a whopping $9.3trn in 2000 ($13.5trn in today’s money). That was more than 20 times the total of foreign direct investment into developing countries over the preceding decade. If small farmers and shantytown-dwellers had clear, legal title to their property, they could borrow money more easily to buy better seeds or start a business. They could invest in their land—by irrigating it or erecting a shop—without fear that someone might one day grab it. Property rights would make the poor richer, he argued.

This article appeared in the Leaders section of the print edition under the headline “Whose land?”

Office politics: The fight over the future of work

From the September 12th 2020 edition

Discover stories from this section and more in the list of contents

Explore the edition

Discover more

This illustration shows an open book with a yellow background. The left page has a green leaf, a bold "n," text, and a declining graph. Small figures on the right turn a blank page, one holding a large yellow pen.

Lessons from the failure of Northvolt

Governments blew billions on a battery champion. Time to welcome foreign investors instead

How to make a success of peace talks with Vladimir Putin

The key is robust security guarantees for Ukrainians


Black and white photograph of Javier Milei

Javier Milei: “My contempt for the state is infinite”

Argentina’s president is idolised by the Trumpian right. They should get to know him better


Tariff threats will do harm, even if Donald Trump does not impose them

The risk of a trade war is uncomfortably high

Peace in Lebanon is just a start

Donald Trump must build on Joe Biden’s belated success

From Nixon to China, to Trump to Tehran

Iran is weak. For America’s next president that creates an opportunity