Finance & economics | Free exchange

Catalonia and the perils of fiscal redistribution

Self-determination is all very well; but what if it masks fiscal selfishness?

POPULISM is the weapon not just of the downtrodden. As the crisis in Catalonia demonstrates, the rich have economic anxieties of their own. Catalonia has an identity distinct, in important ways, from that of the rest of Spain. But the recent drive for independence has been energised by anger over the flow of fiscal redistribution from rich Catalans to their countrymen: people seen, in parts of the restless north-east, as thankless and lazy as well as alien. Paradoxically, globalisation has inflamed separatism around the world by raising the question Catalans now confront: to whom, exactly, do we owe a sense of social responsibility?

This article appeared in the Finance & economics section of the print edition under the headline “Who is my neighbour?”

Do social media threaten democracy?

From the November 4th 2017 edition

Discover stories from this section and more in the list of contents

Explore the edition

Discover more

A float is inflated in preparation for the Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade.

Why everyone wants to lend to weak companies

An unanticipated side-effect of Donald Trump’s election

People march in the annual Veteran's Day Parade in New York.

American veterans now receive absurdly generous benefits

An enormous rise in disability payments may complicate debt-reduction efforts


Calendar with shopping related iconography in each day

Why Black Friday sales grow more annoying every year

Nobody is to blame. Everyone suffers


Trump wastes no time in reigniting trade wars

Canada and Mexico look likely to suffer

How Trump, Starmer and Macron can avoid a debt crunch

With deficits soaring, their finance ministers will have to be smart

What Scott Bessent’s appointment means for the Trump administration

The president-elect’s nominee for treasury secretary faces a gruelling job