Culture | Great-power decline

Rome fell. Will the modern-day West follow suit?

“Why Empires Fall” makes a diverting historical comparison, if not a wholly convincing one

Unknown Artist, (19th century) Odoacre (Odovacar, 435-493), chief of the Herules, obliges the abdication of Romulus Augustule, in Latin Flavius Romulus Augustus (or Romulus Augustulus (in it). Romolo Augustolo), around 460 - 511), last Roman emperor of the west in 476. Chromolithography around 1890. Private Collection chromolithograph 19
Image: Bridgeman Images

DECLINISM is in fashion again. As relations between America and China worsen, studying the ends of earlier ages of hegemony becomes more popular. Books predicting the unstoppable rise of autocratic strongmen and the death of democracy proliferate. There is much talk of the “Thucydides trap”: the inevitability of a clash between a rising power and an established one, as Athens challenged Sparta in the fifth century bc.

This article appeared in the Culture section of the print edition under the headline “Roman lessons”

From the May 27th 2023 edition

Discover stories from this section and more in the list of contents

Explore the edition

More from Culture

Magnus Carlsen of Norway in action at the Freestyle Chess G.O.A.T. Challenge tournament at Weissenhaus, Wangels, Germany, February 12th 2024

Can Magnus Carlsen convince people to watch chess?

The world’s best player hopes that glamming up the ancient game can make stars of its players

A model poses for photographers amongst wildflowers in bloom at Lake Elsinore, California, United States, March 18th 2019

Are internet firms the problem, or are you the problem?

A veteran critic of technology offers his take on a familiar target


An illustration of the Michelin man reclining on a couch, picking a grape from bowl whilst reading a yelp review on a smartphone. Loose pages are scattered near his feet. A shooting star is visible through the window.

The Michelin Guide is no longer the only tastemaker in town

How is it adapting to changing eating habits?


Why “Emilia Pérez” is loved by Hollywood and hated by everyone else

And the Oscar for Worst Picture goes to…

Tofu: never judge a food by its political reputation

Think outside the white plastic box. Here is a carnivore’s guide to tofu

Sex, drugs or chastity?

Pope Francis has written the first memoir by a sitting pope. God help us