Culture | Dashed hopes and bad omens

Might China have followed a more reformist path?

In “Never Turn Back” and “China After Mao”, Julian Gewirtz and Frank Dikötter disagree

Zhao Ziyang with the Chinese and international press at the Thirteenth Party Congress. Jamie FlorCruz Library, 1987

Never Turn Back. By Julian Gewirtz. Belknap Press; 432 pages; $32.95 and £26.95

This article appeared in the Culture section of the print edition under the headline “Dashed hopes and bad omens”

The world China wants

From the October 15th 2022 edition

Discover stories from this section and more in the list of contents

Explore the edition

More from Culture

An illustration of a stack of books that make up the American flag.

Want to spend time with a different American president?

Five presidential biographies to distract you from the news

Eames House, Chautauqua Drive, Pacific Palisades, California

Los Angeles has lost some of its trailblazing architecture

How will it rebuild?


A worker takes down a sign saying "shareholders", immediately after the UBS General Assembly which followed the emergency takeover of Credit Suisse

What firms are for

The framework for thinking about business and capitalism is hopelessly outdated, argues a new book


Greg Gutfeld, America’s most popular late-night host, rules the airwaves

The left gave him his perch

Why matcha, made from green tea, is the drink of the moment

Is it really a healthy alternative to coffee? Not the way Gen Z orders it