China | Chaguan

How China’s bullying could backfire

Humiliating those who defy it does not make them love China’s government

CHINA BULLIES other countries because it works. Once told that they have crossed a “red line” by harming China’s interests or calling out its misdeeds, many governments crumble swiftly. Others fold after suffering months of threats, trade boycotts and cancelled official meetings. But in China’s long experience, almost all—even sometimes America—climb down eventually, sending envoys to sue for peace. True, some Western leaders pay public lip-service to their own country’s values as they land in far-off Beijing. Once the press is shooed from the room, however, the foreign visitors get down to dealmaking. They bow to China’s mix of market power, geopolitical importance and ruthlessness.

This article appeared in the China section of the print edition under the headline “The downside of bullying”

Making coal history

From the December 5th 2020 edition

Discover stories from this section and more in the list of contents

Explore the edition

More from China

Illustration of a translation app translating between Chinese and US english, the text says "this is a" with the options "negotiation", "argument" and "battle" in both English and Chinese

America and China are talking. But much gets lost in translation

How linguistic differences complicate relations between the great powers

A traditional fortune teller waits for customers in his shop in Beijing, China

It’s a good time to be an astrologer in China

In the face of hardship, the country’s youth are embracing superstition


A container terminal in Qingdao, China

The early days of the Trump administration, as viewed from China

A good start, but it could get worse quickly


How (un)popular is China’s Communist Party?

As the economy falters and the social compact frays, Xi Jinping wants to know

An outrage that even China’s supine media has called out

Anger is growing over a form of detention linked to torture and deaths

Why foreign law firms are leaving China

A number of them are in motion to vacate