Asia | Banyan

If a China and America war went nuclear, who would win?

After 45 days of conventional fighting nukes would be tempting, wargamers suggest

Illustration of two nuclear bombs about to smash into each other
Illustration: Lan Truong

IT IS BAD enough to contemplate a war in Asia. It is grimmer still to think through a nuclear one. But somebody has to. And so Andrew Metrick, Philip Sheers and Stacie Pettyjohn, all of the Centre for a New American Security (CNAS), a think-tank in Washington, recently gathered a group of experts to play a tabletop exercise—a type of wargame—to explore how a Sino-American nuclear war could break out. The results were not encouraging.

Explore more

This article appeared in the Asia section of the print edition under the headline “Tabletop annihilation ”

From the August 24th 2024 edition

Discover stories from this section and more in the list of contents

Explore the edition

Discover more

The Adani scandal takes the shine off Modi’s electoral success

The tycoon’s indictment clouds the prime minister’s prospects

Priyanka Gandhi addresses a rally standing in front of an image of herself.

Priyanka Gandhi: dynastic scion, and hope of India’s opposition

Poised to enter parliament, she may have bigger ambitions than that 


Kazakhstan, the Ustyurt plateau. Caspian sea;

The Caspian Sea is shrinking rapidly

This has big implications for Russia, which has come to rely on Central Asian ports


Racial tensions boil over in New Zealand

A controversial bill regarding Maori people punctures its relative harmony

Once a free-market pioneer, Sri Lanka takes a leap to the left

A new president with Marxist roots now dominates parliament too



Discover more

An illustration of Anura Kumara Dissanayake standing at a podium to make a speech above the left side of a two-ended arrow, which is coloured blue on the left side and red on the right.

Once a free-market pioneer, Sri Lanka takes a leap to the left

A new president with Marxist roots now dominates parliament too

An illustration of a cardboard box with writing on the side that reads "FROM: THAILAND, TO: USA" with a postage stamp with the colours of the flag of Thailand. Inside are more cardboard boxes with flags of China and Thailand on one of them.

How South-East Asia can weather the Trump trade typhoon

The complacent region could use an outside jolt


An illustration of a teacup containing two smoking nuclear chimneys, a space rocket, a bag of money with a rupee sign with a teabg label that reads "BJP" hanging down the side of the cup.

What Narendra Modi’s third term may look like

Reading the tea leaves of parliaments past


Yes sir: a bizarre initiation ritual for Indonesia’s cabinet

The newly-inaugurated president sends his ministers to boot camp

Japan is remarkably open to AI, but slow to make use of it

The land of Doraemon embraces the new technology in theory but not in practice

Myanmar’s military junta has conjured up a crazy currency system

Desperate for cash, the Tatmadaw is distorting foreign-exchange markets